This article is taken from PN Review 292, Volume 53 Number 2, November - December 2026.
On Bigness and Not Reading Poems
It is strange, when you think about it, how rare it is to come across an extended close reading of a single lyric poem. The art of verse might lag now behind pub quizzes and cake making in the cultural pecking order, but still – think of all those magazines and journals and web posts, all those English departments, those conferences. And by close reading I mean here two things in particular: a sustained focus on a single poem; and a close reading that is also a close listening, attentive to such features as sound and rhythm.
Why might this be? Notwithstanding PN Review’s welcome status as a home for non-academic writing, our answer needs to start in academia, given this is where so many poets and critics still end up making their beds, before lying awake in them. Or, to put it differently – because this is where the vast majority of what money still attaches to poetry is to be found. The rest of poetry culture – the writing of it, writing about it – more often than not lies downstream from the university, not least because its participants tend to have passed through its walls as students.
While a lot of what calls itself close reading goes on in academia, it is never really of the kind I sketch above. Take the varieties of ‘postcritique’ that emerged in what Rita Felski, in 2014, called the ‘method wars’ – whose details need not detain us here. These varieties rested, in their own account, on some form of attentive engagement with the text ...
Why might this be? Notwithstanding PN Review’s welcome status as a home for non-academic writing, our answer needs to start in academia, given this is where so many poets and critics still end up making their beds, before lying awake in them. Or, to put it differently – because this is where the vast majority of what money still attaches to poetry is to be found. The rest of poetry culture – the writing of it, writing about it – more often than not lies downstream from the university, not least because its participants tend to have passed through its walls as students.
While a lot of what calls itself close reading goes on in academia, it is never really of the kind I sketch above. Take the varieties of ‘postcritique’ that emerged in what Rita Felski, in 2014, called the ‘method wars’ – whose details need not detain us here. These varieties rested, in their own account, on some form of attentive engagement with the text ...
The page you have requested is restricted to subscribers only. Please enter your username and password and click on 'Continue'. Please ensure that you enter your username and password exactly as you specified them, including any capital letters. Your username is not your email address:
If you have forgotten your username and password, please enter the email address you used when you joined. Your login details will then be emailed to the address specified.
If you are not a subscriber and would like to enjoy the 298 issues containing over 11,900 poems, articles, reports, interviews and reviews,
why not subscribe to the website today?
