This article is taken from PN Review 292, Volume 53 Number 2, November - December 2026.
A Gresham’s Law for Culture in the Age of Trump
‘All things solid melt into... schlock’
I recently violated Michael Schmidt’s sensible rule of never commenting on the internet. A long report in the New York Times on the contested political and cultural terrain of museum labels included a statement by a neo-conservative political commentator that it was risible to find ideological meaning in seventeenth-century Dutch still-life paintings. They were simply fruit and veg, nothing else. Rising, unwisely, to the bait I responded to the contrary that there was a substantial art historiographical literature linking Dutch painting to the rise of capitalism, overseas expansion, and – yes – slavery and forced labour. I went on, again unwisely, to say that people who didn’t know what they were talking about shouldn’t express opinions they couldn’t support. I may or may not have used the epithet ‘philistines’. I know, right? I also, since the article was about how the Smithsonian Institution has become a flashpoint in the culture wars, identified myself as a long-term employee of the Institution’s National Portrait Gallery. For my pains, I received an angry response that ‘a lot of Americans would say’ that I, and ‘woke’ intellectuals like me, were the cause of the problems afflicting museums and, more generally, attitudes like mine were driving the widening ‘cultural chasm’ that undermined our national unity. I, for once wisely, did not respond. But what I wanted to say to my anonymous critic was, ‘a lot of Americans don’t know what they’re talking about. And a lot of Americans get very angry when you point this out to them.’
To stay with art work, for the moment, Americans are particularly resistant to finding meaning beyond the surface appearance of the painting and its subject. ‘Ceci est un pipe’, as Magritte didn’t say. A table loaded with the products of Dutch agriculture and greenhouses is simply the visual simulacrum of the real things: apples, oranges, a cut of beef, a carafe of wine et al. While there is a general agreement that portraits can enhance their subjects, making them look better than they were, history paintings are contested terrain. As the pioneering military historian John Keegan made clear in his The Face of Battle, paintings of the Battle of Waterloo depicted an order and coherence that was absent on the battlefield and using that visual evidence blocked us from understanding both the battle and Napoleonic-era war. But meanings are resisted especially if the visual evidence does not align with deeply held beliefs about personal and national values. To take a trivial (and amusing) case, the sculptor Horatio Greenough created a national scandal and an artistic failure when he depicted, in monumental marble and modelled on an ancient statue of Zeus, a seated George Washington (1840) naked from the waist up. Intended as heroic, the depiction of an undraped Father of his Country was derided as untrue to Washington’s character and demeanour as well as simply unseemly due to its nudity. Far better the decorous offerings of Gilbert Stuart and Charles Willson Peale which conform to our expectations of the great man even if they are equally imagined. (Last time I checked, this statue was consigned to a space under an escalator at the National Museum of American History.) With the rise of abstraction, lack of comprehension and bewilderment grew apace among an audience untutored in its intellectual origins (the breakdown of forms, the flattening of perspective, etc.) One can apprehend an apple but what can one make of the ‘scribbles’ of a Cy Twombly; ‘my twelve-year-old could do that’ is a frequent epithet, indicative of a consensus that modern art lacks the craft, skill and mastery of traditional artists. Impressionism is enduringly popular because it is only a mild abstraction of reality; the subject – haystacks, Notre Dame – remains coherent and visible to the viewer through the play of light imparted by the artist’s brush. You don’t have to understand the intricacies of art history to ‘get it’.
Much of the mainstream attitude to looking and judging art can be attributed to good old Anglo-American empiricism. An object is complete in and of itself and can be understood on those terms. Moreover, a democratic ideology rooted in ‘common sense’ located authority in the individual. The revolutionary potentialities of individualism with its devolution of authoritative structures always provoked conservative fears, from Burke to Allan Bloom, of the ‘mob,’ and that standards would collapse as appetite overcame reason. Henry Ford’s famous remark, ‘History is bunk’, cuts both ways: on the one hand, it signalled a rejection of precedent and the dead hand of the past, allowing him the freedom to revolutionize industry; on the other, it opened the door to a general attack on the illegitimacy of all institutions and knowledge. ‘I don’t know art but I know what I like’ could indicate a refreshing iconoclasm, but it also contained the seed of an anti-intellectual refusal to learn. American conservatism has always been an uneasy alliance between elite proponents of high culture and a populace suspicious of ‘book learning’, hostile to intellectuals and institutions such as universities and museums. Art, and intellectual pursuits such as the humanities, are easy targets for the populist right because they can be caricatured as useless, their practitioners lazy parasites and, most damningly, un-American because intellectual inquiry is too questioning of authority, including the history of the United States itself.
The Smithsonian, which has been under prolonged attack from the Trump administration and right-wing ideologues, is especially at risk because it is the national museum. Located on the Mall, between the Capitol and the White House, it is seen by many people as another Washington monument, not as a museum like the Guggenheim or Crystal Bridges. As a monument, it is expected to exemplify, even glorify, American achievements; as the curator of the Air and Space Museum put it, ‘We don’t do plane crashes’. The tone is expected to be reverential and controversy free. As I learned to my cost writing labels and wall texts at the Portrait Gallery, including any critical material on a subject would draw a rebuke. And including anything like even an editorial judgement based on the historiographical consensus was also taboo. I once described Carl Sandburg as an inferior poet to Robert Frost and paid for my sin.
The greater problem is the inclusion of subjects and topics that are either controversial or invite an interrogation of the popular consensus on the virtues of American democratic culture. In 1976, for the bicentennial, American History did an exhibition on the treatment of Japanese Americans during the Second World War in order to explore the limits of democracy. It excited controversy, as it was intended to do, but was not taken down, a result that would be inconceivable today. A subsequent exhibition on the ending of the war with Japan was cancelled because it interrogated the decision making on the use of the atomic bomb. In 1991, the Smithsonian’s American Art Museum questioned the cliches and shibboleths of frontier history in a show called ‘The West as America’ and was reviled by mainstream curators such as Daniel Boorstin. It flummoxed its critics that paintings of heroic cowboys by Frederick Remington were composed, not in the Dakota Badlands but on a tenement roof in Brooklyn. The idea that history is not a fixed or frozen set of facts but rather that those facts can be interrogated and questioned was very upsetting for people uncomfortable with nuance and multiple perspectives. Criticizing facts is taken as criticism of America. The idea that history could change is inconceivable – and anathema.
My exhibition ‘Hide/Seek. Difference and Desire in American Portraiture’ (2010) at the National Portrait Gallery was a masterpiece show of American art but was savaged because it addressed issues of gender ambiguity in works from Thomas Eakins to Felix Gonzalez Torres. Entering the fraught territory of sexual difference and gender drew the fire of critics who refused to consider the ambiguities of human identity. The issue wasn’t just the artworks themselves (although we were careful to include chaste Mapplethorpes!) but the idea of who was eligible to be represented in the museum, and, by extension, in society itself. The established consensus that diversifying and representing inclusion is a positive good is definitely breaking down. The Trump attack on DEI (Diversity, Equity, Inclusion) in workplace hiring has metastasized into who can be visible in public, both physically, as in the ICE crackdown in the streets, and symbolically, seen on the walls of our national museums. The message is clear: Blacks, women, gay and queer people and other populations are not American.
Trump made his career as a builder. The event that launched him politically was his takeover in 1986 of the renovation of the Wollman skating rink in Central Park: after years of governmental and bureaucratic shillyshallying a disgusted Trump stepped in and had his company do the job. This positioned Trump (and his family) as the can-do antidote to the paralysis of late twentieth-century government, the sclerotic remains of a once vibrant New Deal and Great Society liberalism. The Trump empire, golf courses and deluxe skyscrapers, grew apace. But what happened next remains biographically obscure. The people I know who knew Trump, both socially and politically, say he was basically a nice guy – he was famous for sending little ‘attaboy’ notes to people who made the news – a moderate northeastern Republican; his support of abortion rights has been buried. A star turn on ‘The Apprentice’, firing people who didn’t perform, fed his ego. The notorious White House correspondent’s dinner where President Obama and others viciously insulted him was doubtless triggering. Being roasted by the liberal establishment, whose gatherings at Davos, Nantucket or the Metropolitan’s fashion gala he desperately wanted to join, transformed his resentment from private grievance to public rage. ‘I’ll show them’ was the vow and so he has, burning down the state and the public sphere, falteringly in his first term and full bore in the second. Once a builder, Trump is now a wrecker.
The demographic makeup of Trump’s electoral coalition – from neo-Nazis and other racists to remnants of the dispossessed working class to opportunistic tech bros – will be the subject of future psephological inquiry. At the present moment, what can be said is that Trump gave people, faced with a confusing, conflict ridden world which is difficult to understand, permission to act out their worst instincts, unleashing the collective Id, freeing it from the Super Ego. When Francis Fukuyama optimistically proclaimed the End of History after the fall of Soviet communism, he envisaged a new era of steady-state liberal democracy evolving frictionlessly through time. Not for the first time a liberal rationalism, steeped in the ideals of the Enlightenment, underestimated the threat of atavistic nationalism and irrationality (even stupidity) to liberal rationalism. Based on his bombastic talent as a businessman/huckster skating from one dubious project to another – Trump steaks, Trump vodka, Trump casinos, Trump University et al – Trump’s political career has weaponized a crude nationalism through exaggeration, dissembling and distortion, all delivered incessantly and at top volume. The ceaseless din is punctuated by a rhetorical crudity of previously unimaginable scope: vulgarity, insults and cursing are Trump’s stock in trade. He is the first president, actually the first politician, to curse in public speeches. Richard Nixon’s private vulgarity, revealed in the Watergate Tapes, shocked the nation. Now not so much.
Conservatives used to bemoan the dumbing down and coarsening of American culture as integral to their attack on ‘permissive’ Democrats, the counterculture and Black people. Concern about the decline of culture disappeared once the billionaire political phenomenon of Donald Trump was in power and enforcing his will via a bombardment of threats. Indeed, a swaggering, profane masculinity, one modelled on mob bosses such as John Gotti, has come into vogue, turning even previously wonkish policy makers into hard-boiled capos de regime. Trump’s oversized suits, the long ties and omnipresent overcoat mimic the sartorial style of the ‘Dapper Don’ who in the 1980s shared the gossip columns of the New York tabloids with him. The language of The Godfather peppers otherwise mundane business meetings: ‘going to the mattresses’, ‘wartime consigliore’, ‘it’s not personal, it’s just business’, and, of course, ‘I’ll make him an offer he can’t refuse’. Talking about ‘whacking’ a political or ideological opponent is not just a signal of the failure of civility and comity, a shared sense of civic duty regardless of partisan disagreement, but a dehumanization which can have dire consequences, from incarceration and deportation to actual killing, both by lone gunmen and instruments of the state.
Marx and Engels famously wrote that under capitalism ‘all that is solid, melts into air’. They meant the big structures of the economy and society, church and family especially. Their diagnosis has been fruitful in examining many facets of civic life. To go deeper into a critique of cultural practice, it’s a classical economist who offers an insightful analogy. In 1857, Henry D. Macleod formulated ‘Gresham’s Law’ to describe how bad currency drives out good. The Law was named after the Elizabethan financier Sir Thomas Gresham who urged the reform of English specie currency plagued by adulteration (counterfeiting, coin clipping etc). The debased currency circulated in place of authentic silver and gold coinage. Applied culturally, Gresham’s Law explains how the institutional collapse indicated by Marx and Engels now permeates and corrodes fundamental epistemological structures, including rationality, the scientific method and even grammar. Trump is both cause and symptom of this intellectual and cultural collapse. Bad culture drives out good. Simple drives out complex. Ignorance drives out knowledge.
Historically, there have been very few brakes on the expansion of American business. As Antonio Gramsci summarized, there are none of the ‘viscous’ elements (feudal remnants, the landed gentry etc.) that checked or impeded European capitalism. By the late nineteenth century, economic and social inequality had got so extreme that a loose coalition of ‘progressives’, led by some members of the elite itself including future president Theodore Roosevelt, inaugurated a period of regulation. Interestingly, one reason for this self-regulation was aesthetic: the ‘Robber Barons’ had taken to unseemly displays of wealth – the lavish Bradley-Martin Ball of 1897 flashed a warning that things had gone too far. The costume ball cost about $15 million in today’s money and the theme, if you can believe it, celebrated the ancien régime. Mrs. Martin came as Mary Stuart and she wore $60,000 in jewels; her husband was Louis XV. It was too over-the-top, and a chastened plutocracy vowed to be more discreet in the future.
At least many of the Robber Barons had good taste, hiring the best architects for their houses and patronizing artists like John Singer Sargent for their portraits. Andrew Carnegie’s The Gospel of Wealth (1889) sketched out a program of civic stewardship for the rich, the underwriting of museums, libraries, schools and universities for societal betterment; Carnegie built about 1680 public libraries in the United States. A consortium of New York merchants built and endowed the Metropolitan Museum of Art. Such institution building was not limited to cosmopolitan New York. In Kansas City, one of the great American art museums, the Nelson-Atkins, was built on the bequests of two local fortunes, a story that was replicated in other cities and states. Today’s billionaire plutocracy evidences little of this public spiritedness even as they seek to privatize and monetize the functions of government; allowing Bezos and Musk to run the space programme seems especially dangerous for national security reasons. It’s slightly surprising that there hasn’t been a call to privatize the Smithsonian.
Older elites found social status and public esteem by associating themselves with the cultural capital of great art. Today’s plutocracy may just not be comfortable with things such as art or traditional media such as writing. Instead, as their wealth derives chiefly from the cyberworld and sales, image is everything and personal branding is key, through online portals in the virtual world such as Facebook, Twitter/X and Instagram/TikTok. The internet’s initial promise to expand the public sphere, enabling communities of interest to come together in fruitful discourse, quickly disappeared, foundering on an inability to regulate speech. Reasonable debate disappeared as people realized they could use the anonymity of internet ‘conversation’ to wrench the conversation off track, frequently through a barrage of invective and insults. (In 2015, the wonderful Carol Rumens – RIP – chose one of my poems for her Guardian ‘Poem of the Week’: about the tenth public comment, ostensibly on the poem, was how I looked like a right numpty in my author’s photo.) In this race to the bottom, the full range of modern pathologies – from body shaming to racism – was deployed, further coarsening and poisoning public culture.
For the general public, social media was sold as a platform to display one’s individuality and creativity. In fact, it was a way for mega corporations to cull personal data for advertising and sales purposes; the rise of the ‘influencer’ as a guide to both personal wellbeing and material achievement was a by-blow of this advertising surge. Far from letting a zillion flowers bloom it actually flattened culture into an indigestible mass of comments and images. The internet basically destroyed the magazine and journal as a source for news and opinion; daily newspapers are hanging on in a few national locales but are under threat. The corrosive effect of the internet upended traditional methods of peer review, fact checking and verification, including the disappearance of editing from book production. My experience on Wikipedia with subjects I know well is that, despite its claim of accuracy through the marketplace of ideas, it is significantly more prone to error than the older publications such as the Encyclopedia Britannica; its open entry format also makes it unstable, subject to the attentions of enthusiasts, cranks and people with axes to grind. What cannot be emphasized enough is that the main achievement of social media and the internet is that it facilitates lying, not least to ourselves. Trump has weaponized social media, turning it into a force multiplier for his lies, falsehoods and grievances, burying his opponents in a bewildering flood of invective.
It is remarkable that people still believe that the social media/internet cyber-complex is an avenue for self-expression and creativity. A new job description in public culture is ‘creatives’, but with no indication what the person is ‘creative’ at except for posting on the internet. A large percentage of users, roughly 20 to 30, describe themselves as content creatives. Some of their work, in online zines or platforms like Substack, may actually involve creating something, most frequently writing or photographs. Much of it though is advertising, not least for oneself. The phenomenon of the selfie is ubiquitous. Look at me! The reward isn’t the satisfaction of making something but the dopamine hit of getting ‘likes’ or comments. And there’s also the pathetic phenomenon of the parasocial relationship: imagining you are part of a community or are friends with someone because you follow them on social media. I’m besties with Dua Lipa myself.
As the internet collapsed traditional editorial guidelines and guardrails, so has it helped implode distinctions among and between types and genres of culture. Under modernity and now post-modernity, there has always been a churn between high and low, elite and vernacular. Most famously, probably, is how free verse interacted with formalism during the democratic nineteenth century. Jazz and folk rhythms invigorated classical music. But now these cultural and artistic interactions all seem to be going one way: everything is becoming popular culture. There is a political impetus to this change. The right’s attack on so-called ‘woke’ ideology evidences a disdain for culture across all disciplines. The administration’s attack on Washington’s Kennedy Center is a tip-off of how deep the vitriol against established artforms runs. The Kennedy Center has always been a reliable purveyor of mainstream, safe artistic productions for middle-class, middle-brow Americans who want a little culture: Broadway musicals, the established repertoire in classical music, ballet troupes doing selections from the canon. (It most recently was run by a Republican apparatchik who curried favour, to no avail, by mounting an egregious exhibition of George W. Bush’s painting.) That the administration would go after such a safe space is clear evidence of an anti-intellectualism that goes deep. The accompanying attacks on the universities and the Library of Congress are part of this violent antipathy to art, books, and thought itself.
But when the US president puts on a mixed martial arts event on the White House lawn, you can take that as an indicator of where things are going. Future historians will find a fruitful subject in the aesthetic and stylistic links between Trump and professional wrestling. I quite like car racing but putting on an Indy car race through the streets of Washington in late August smacks more of Nero flooding the Coliseum to hold naval battles than Monte Carlo. The destruction of the White House East Wing to build a ballroom, the uprooting of the famous Rose Garden to install a concrete ‘café’ space, the gimcrackery of the decorations (more gilt!) in the Oval Office and public spaces all indicate a contempt for historical precedent and American culture. The curated artworks of previous administrations – the two Bushes favoured emblematic American landscapes; the Obamas displayed the first abstractions (and were criticized for it, of course) – have been replaced by machine-painted photo-realist depictions of the President. Trump is all appetite, no taste. He likes his steak well done, with ketchup. And his late-evening snack is a McDonald’s Big Mac which he picks apart before chowing down.
It ought to be the easiest thing in the world to put on a celebration for America’s 250th birthday. Indeed, the Smithsonian assembled a programme displaying the full range of American culture, rich offerings from Springsteen to the National Symphony with accompanying exhibitions, lectures, readings and so on. The administration scrapped that plan for its ‘Country Fair’ concept, in which the several states (not everyone participated) displayed a motley collection of local wares on the National Mall. It was a failure conceptually and drew pitiful attendance. The ‘Country Fair’ idea was meant to appeal to states’ rights, to good old American values and plain folks, as opposed to the cosmopolitan elites with their un-American ideals and programmes. Looming over the ‘Country Fair’ was one of Trump’s triumphal arches, which, while striving for neoclassical monumentalism, looked like the pathetic ruin of some tin-pot dictator; hastily constructed, it delaminated in the Washington heat. The whole thing was a downmarket version of the National Socialist ‘Kinder, Küche, Kirche’, a call to a mythical past to resist the corruptions and anxieties of modernism. Amazingly, one of the Southern states in the ‘Fair’ included a baptismal tank where the converted could be saved. If you’re inclined, you can draw your own historical analogies to 1930s book burnings and the exhibition of ‘Degenerate Art’. Once as tragedy, then as farce, as the saying goes.
Despite the clear danger that Trump and his epigones pose to American democracy and the damage that they are doing every day, it’s hard to look away from the sheer buffoonery and incompetence of the man and his programme. America has the world’s best pool cleaning industry, yet the administration has botched the maintenance of the Reflecting Pool between the Washington and Lincoln monuments. As I write, the administration has launched a counter blast to the woke Smithsonian by putting on an exhibition – Passport to Patriotism – of properly patriotic art curated by the State Department and located at the Art Museum of the Americas. Concocted by Artificial Intelligence and machine-made, the ‘artworks’ displayed are not even as good as the kind of mass-produced paintings one finds in mid-level motels. In 1938 Germany mounted an exhibition called Great German Art as an opposition to the abstractions of ‘degenerate art’. It displayed traditional art that tended towards kitsch: bucolic landscapes, sentimental genre scenes and buxom milkmaids. An attempt at something similar, Passport to Patriotism can’t even rise to the level of kitsch: it’s dreck. Sparkly American flags abound and especially egregious are the airbrushed and outsized portraits of the Founders (Jefferson, Washington et al.) derived from original artwork by Gilbert Stuart and the Peales. Not only are they terrible, but you can go up the street to the National Portrait Gallery and see the originals! (If you don’t believe me, the New York Times of 30 July has illustrations as well as reporting on the corrupt dealings between curators and artists that went into the show’s making.)
The actuarial tables will take care of Mr. Trump. His declining popularity in his second term, as well as multiple setbacks both legally and politically, are a hopeful straw in the wind. What happens afterwards, as MAGA’s guiding light goes out, remains to be seen; one suspects the knives will come out as contenders jostle for the throne. Absent the fever dreams instigated by Trump, perhaps some of his supporters might conclude that ‘owning the Libs’ is not a viable programme for governance. Middle- and working-class supporters of the Republican Party might also think about whether their billionaire leaders have their best interests at heart. Awaiting that day, liberals of both the old fashioned and progressive kind need to harden themselves to resist where they can. It would be helpful if cultural leaders at universities, museums and elsewhere could articulate a stronger defence of the values of the humanities and science, including rationalism itself, than they have done so far. Personally, I’d like to see more politically engaged poetry and fiction, a counter culture if you will, grounded in carrying on the traditions of the past. There is also value in maintaining the traditions and lineage of the disciplines – a belief in the intrinsic value of the arts and humanities – especially when they’re under threat; as Elizabeth Bishop commanded, ‘Write it’. Politically, a complacent liberalism has declined into a programmatic formalism that does little to address the genuine hardship and bewilderment faced by ordinary people. Truth be told, the Democratic Party in the USA has given voters little reason to feel good about America since the end of the Vietnam War. Into that void has stepped the atavistic, toxic nationalism of MAGA. We should be chastened by the costs of our cultural and civic failures.
It is difficult
to get the news from poems
yet men die miserably every
day
for lack
of what is found there.
– William Carlos Williams
‘The answer to all your questions is money.’
– Bob Arum, boxing promoter
I recently violated Michael Schmidt’s sensible rule of never commenting on the internet. A long report in the New York Times on the contested political and cultural terrain of museum labels included a statement by a neo-conservative political commentator that it was risible to find ideological meaning in seventeenth-century Dutch still-life paintings. They were simply fruit and veg, nothing else. Rising, unwisely, to the bait I responded to the contrary that there was a substantial art historiographical literature linking Dutch painting to the rise of capitalism, overseas expansion, and – yes – slavery and forced labour. I went on, again unwisely, to say that people who didn’t know what they were talking about shouldn’t express opinions they couldn’t support. I may or may not have used the epithet ‘philistines’. I know, right? I also, since the article was about how the Smithsonian Institution has become a flashpoint in the culture wars, identified myself as a long-term employee of the Institution’s National Portrait Gallery. For my pains, I received an angry response that ‘a lot of Americans would say’ that I, and ‘woke’ intellectuals like me, were the cause of the problems afflicting museums and, more generally, attitudes like mine were driving the widening ‘cultural chasm’ that undermined our national unity. I, for once wisely, did not respond. But what I wanted to say to my anonymous critic was, ‘a lot of Americans don’t know what they’re talking about. And a lot of Americans get very angry when you point this out to them.’
To stay with art work, for the moment, Americans are particularly resistant to finding meaning beyond the surface appearance of the painting and its subject. ‘Ceci est un pipe’, as Magritte didn’t say. A table loaded with the products of Dutch agriculture and greenhouses is simply the visual simulacrum of the real things: apples, oranges, a cut of beef, a carafe of wine et al. While there is a general agreement that portraits can enhance their subjects, making them look better than they were, history paintings are contested terrain. As the pioneering military historian John Keegan made clear in his The Face of Battle, paintings of the Battle of Waterloo depicted an order and coherence that was absent on the battlefield and using that visual evidence blocked us from understanding both the battle and Napoleonic-era war. But meanings are resisted especially if the visual evidence does not align with deeply held beliefs about personal and national values. To take a trivial (and amusing) case, the sculptor Horatio Greenough created a national scandal and an artistic failure when he depicted, in monumental marble and modelled on an ancient statue of Zeus, a seated George Washington (1840) naked from the waist up. Intended as heroic, the depiction of an undraped Father of his Country was derided as untrue to Washington’s character and demeanour as well as simply unseemly due to its nudity. Far better the decorous offerings of Gilbert Stuart and Charles Willson Peale which conform to our expectations of the great man even if they are equally imagined. (Last time I checked, this statue was consigned to a space under an escalator at the National Museum of American History.) With the rise of abstraction, lack of comprehension and bewilderment grew apace among an audience untutored in its intellectual origins (the breakdown of forms, the flattening of perspective, etc.) One can apprehend an apple but what can one make of the ‘scribbles’ of a Cy Twombly; ‘my twelve-year-old could do that’ is a frequent epithet, indicative of a consensus that modern art lacks the craft, skill and mastery of traditional artists. Impressionism is enduringly popular because it is only a mild abstraction of reality; the subject – haystacks, Notre Dame – remains coherent and visible to the viewer through the play of light imparted by the artist’s brush. You don’t have to understand the intricacies of art history to ‘get it’.
Much of the mainstream attitude to looking and judging art can be attributed to good old Anglo-American empiricism. An object is complete in and of itself and can be understood on those terms. Moreover, a democratic ideology rooted in ‘common sense’ located authority in the individual. The revolutionary potentialities of individualism with its devolution of authoritative structures always provoked conservative fears, from Burke to Allan Bloom, of the ‘mob,’ and that standards would collapse as appetite overcame reason. Henry Ford’s famous remark, ‘History is bunk’, cuts both ways: on the one hand, it signalled a rejection of precedent and the dead hand of the past, allowing him the freedom to revolutionize industry; on the other, it opened the door to a general attack on the illegitimacy of all institutions and knowledge. ‘I don’t know art but I know what I like’ could indicate a refreshing iconoclasm, but it also contained the seed of an anti-intellectual refusal to learn. American conservatism has always been an uneasy alliance between elite proponents of high culture and a populace suspicious of ‘book learning’, hostile to intellectuals and institutions such as universities and museums. Art, and intellectual pursuits such as the humanities, are easy targets for the populist right because they can be caricatured as useless, their practitioners lazy parasites and, most damningly, un-American because intellectual inquiry is too questioning of authority, including the history of the United States itself.
The Smithsonian, which has been under prolonged attack from the Trump administration and right-wing ideologues, is especially at risk because it is the national museum. Located on the Mall, between the Capitol and the White House, it is seen by many people as another Washington monument, not as a museum like the Guggenheim or Crystal Bridges. As a monument, it is expected to exemplify, even glorify, American achievements; as the curator of the Air and Space Museum put it, ‘We don’t do plane crashes’. The tone is expected to be reverential and controversy free. As I learned to my cost writing labels and wall texts at the Portrait Gallery, including any critical material on a subject would draw a rebuke. And including anything like even an editorial judgement based on the historiographical consensus was also taboo. I once described Carl Sandburg as an inferior poet to Robert Frost and paid for my sin.
The greater problem is the inclusion of subjects and topics that are either controversial or invite an interrogation of the popular consensus on the virtues of American democratic culture. In 1976, for the bicentennial, American History did an exhibition on the treatment of Japanese Americans during the Second World War in order to explore the limits of democracy. It excited controversy, as it was intended to do, but was not taken down, a result that would be inconceivable today. A subsequent exhibition on the ending of the war with Japan was cancelled because it interrogated the decision making on the use of the atomic bomb. In 1991, the Smithsonian’s American Art Museum questioned the cliches and shibboleths of frontier history in a show called ‘The West as America’ and was reviled by mainstream curators such as Daniel Boorstin. It flummoxed its critics that paintings of heroic cowboys by Frederick Remington were composed, not in the Dakota Badlands but on a tenement roof in Brooklyn. The idea that history is not a fixed or frozen set of facts but rather that those facts can be interrogated and questioned was very upsetting for people uncomfortable with nuance and multiple perspectives. Criticizing facts is taken as criticism of America. The idea that history could change is inconceivable – and anathema.
My exhibition ‘Hide/Seek. Difference and Desire in American Portraiture’ (2010) at the National Portrait Gallery was a masterpiece show of American art but was savaged because it addressed issues of gender ambiguity in works from Thomas Eakins to Felix Gonzalez Torres. Entering the fraught territory of sexual difference and gender drew the fire of critics who refused to consider the ambiguities of human identity. The issue wasn’t just the artworks themselves (although we were careful to include chaste Mapplethorpes!) but the idea of who was eligible to be represented in the museum, and, by extension, in society itself. The established consensus that diversifying and representing inclusion is a positive good is definitely breaking down. The Trump attack on DEI (Diversity, Equity, Inclusion) in workplace hiring has metastasized into who can be visible in public, both physically, as in the ICE crackdown in the streets, and symbolically, seen on the walls of our national museums. The message is clear: Blacks, women, gay and queer people and other populations are not American.
Trump made his career as a builder. The event that launched him politically was his takeover in 1986 of the renovation of the Wollman skating rink in Central Park: after years of governmental and bureaucratic shillyshallying a disgusted Trump stepped in and had his company do the job. This positioned Trump (and his family) as the can-do antidote to the paralysis of late twentieth-century government, the sclerotic remains of a once vibrant New Deal and Great Society liberalism. The Trump empire, golf courses and deluxe skyscrapers, grew apace. But what happened next remains biographically obscure. The people I know who knew Trump, both socially and politically, say he was basically a nice guy – he was famous for sending little ‘attaboy’ notes to people who made the news – a moderate northeastern Republican; his support of abortion rights has been buried. A star turn on ‘The Apprentice’, firing people who didn’t perform, fed his ego. The notorious White House correspondent’s dinner where President Obama and others viciously insulted him was doubtless triggering. Being roasted by the liberal establishment, whose gatherings at Davos, Nantucket or the Metropolitan’s fashion gala he desperately wanted to join, transformed his resentment from private grievance to public rage. ‘I’ll show them’ was the vow and so he has, burning down the state and the public sphere, falteringly in his first term and full bore in the second. Once a builder, Trump is now a wrecker.
The demographic makeup of Trump’s electoral coalition – from neo-Nazis and other racists to remnants of the dispossessed working class to opportunistic tech bros – will be the subject of future psephological inquiry. At the present moment, what can be said is that Trump gave people, faced with a confusing, conflict ridden world which is difficult to understand, permission to act out their worst instincts, unleashing the collective Id, freeing it from the Super Ego. When Francis Fukuyama optimistically proclaimed the End of History after the fall of Soviet communism, he envisaged a new era of steady-state liberal democracy evolving frictionlessly through time. Not for the first time a liberal rationalism, steeped in the ideals of the Enlightenment, underestimated the threat of atavistic nationalism and irrationality (even stupidity) to liberal rationalism. Based on his bombastic talent as a businessman/huckster skating from one dubious project to another – Trump steaks, Trump vodka, Trump casinos, Trump University et al – Trump’s political career has weaponized a crude nationalism through exaggeration, dissembling and distortion, all delivered incessantly and at top volume. The ceaseless din is punctuated by a rhetorical crudity of previously unimaginable scope: vulgarity, insults and cursing are Trump’s stock in trade. He is the first president, actually the first politician, to curse in public speeches. Richard Nixon’s private vulgarity, revealed in the Watergate Tapes, shocked the nation. Now not so much.
Conservatives used to bemoan the dumbing down and coarsening of American culture as integral to their attack on ‘permissive’ Democrats, the counterculture and Black people. Concern about the decline of culture disappeared once the billionaire political phenomenon of Donald Trump was in power and enforcing his will via a bombardment of threats. Indeed, a swaggering, profane masculinity, one modelled on mob bosses such as John Gotti, has come into vogue, turning even previously wonkish policy makers into hard-boiled capos de regime. Trump’s oversized suits, the long ties and omnipresent overcoat mimic the sartorial style of the ‘Dapper Don’ who in the 1980s shared the gossip columns of the New York tabloids with him. The language of The Godfather peppers otherwise mundane business meetings: ‘going to the mattresses’, ‘wartime consigliore’, ‘it’s not personal, it’s just business’, and, of course, ‘I’ll make him an offer he can’t refuse’. Talking about ‘whacking’ a political or ideological opponent is not just a signal of the failure of civility and comity, a shared sense of civic duty regardless of partisan disagreement, but a dehumanization which can have dire consequences, from incarceration and deportation to actual killing, both by lone gunmen and instruments of the state.
Marx and Engels famously wrote that under capitalism ‘all that is solid, melts into air’. They meant the big structures of the economy and society, church and family especially. Their diagnosis has been fruitful in examining many facets of civic life. To go deeper into a critique of cultural practice, it’s a classical economist who offers an insightful analogy. In 1857, Henry D. Macleod formulated ‘Gresham’s Law’ to describe how bad currency drives out good. The Law was named after the Elizabethan financier Sir Thomas Gresham who urged the reform of English specie currency plagued by adulteration (counterfeiting, coin clipping etc). The debased currency circulated in place of authentic silver and gold coinage. Applied culturally, Gresham’s Law explains how the institutional collapse indicated by Marx and Engels now permeates and corrodes fundamental epistemological structures, including rationality, the scientific method and even grammar. Trump is both cause and symptom of this intellectual and cultural collapse. Bad culture drives out good. Simple drives out complex. Ignorance drives out knowledge.
Historically, there have been very few brakes on the expansion of American business. As Antonio Gramsci summarized, there are none of the ‘viscous’ elements (feudal remnants, the landed gentry etc.) that checked or impeded European capitalism. By the late nineteenth century, economic and social inequality had got so extreme that a loose coalition of ‘progressives’, led by some members of the elite itself including future president Theodore Roosevelt, inaugurated a period of regulation. Interestingly, one reason for this self-regulation was aesthetic: the ‘Robber Barons’ had taken to unseemly displays of wealth – the lavish Bradley-Martin Ball of 1897 flashed a warning that things had gone too far. The costume ball cost about $15 million in today’s money and the theme, if you can believe it, celebrated the ancien régime. Mrs. Martin came as Mary Stuart and she wore $60,000 in jewels; her husband was Louis XV. It was too over-the-top, and a chastened plutocracy vowed to be more discreet in the future.
At least many of the Robber Barons had good taste, hiring the best architects for their houses and patronizing artists like John Singer Sargent for their portraits. Andrew Carnegie’s The Gospel of Wealth (1889) sketched out a program of civic stewardship for the rich, the underwriting of museums, libraries, schools and universities for societal betterment; Carnegie built about 1680 public libraries in the United States. A consortium of New York merchants built and endowed the Metropolitan Museum of Art. Such institution building was not limited to cosmopolitan New York. In Kansas City, one of the great American art museums, the Nelson-Atkins, was built on the bequests of two local fortunes, a story that was replicated in other cities and states. Today’s billionaire plutocracy evidences little of this public spiritedness even as they seek to privatize and monetize the functions of government; allowing Bezos and Musk to run the space programme seems especially dangerous for national security reasons. It’s slightly surprising that there hasn’t been a call to privatize the Smithsonian.
Older elites found social status and public esteem by associating themselves with the cultural capital of great art. Today’s plutocracy may just not be comfortable with things such as art or traditional media such as writing. Instead, as their wealth derives chiefly from the cyberworld and sales, image is everything and personal branding is key, through online portals in the virtual world such as Facebook, Twitter/X and Instagram/TikTok. The internet’s initial promise to expand the public sphere, enabling communities of interest to come together in fruitful discourse, quickly disappeared, foundering on an inability to regulate speech. Reasonable debate disappeared as people realized they could use the anonymity of internet ‘conversation’ to wrench the conversation off track, frequently through a barrage of invective and insults. (In 2015, the wonderful Carol Rumens – RIP – chose one of my poems for her Guardian ‘Poem of the Week’: about the tenth public comment, ostensibly on the poem, was how I looked like a right numpty in my author’s photo.) In this race to the bottom, the full range of modern pathologies – from body shaming to racism – was deployed, further coarsening and poisoning public culture.
For the general public, social media was sold as a platform to display one’s individuality and creativity. In fact, it was a way for mega corporations to cull personal data for advertising and sales purposes; the rise of the ‘influencer’ as a guide to both personal wellbeing and material achievement was a by-blow of this advertising surge. Far from letting a zillion flowers bloom it actually flattened culture into an indigestible mass of comments and images. The internet basically destroyed the magazine and journal as a source for news and opinion; daily newspapers are hanging on in a few national locales but are under threat. The corrosive effect of the internet upended traditional methods of peer review, fact checking and verification, including the disappearance of editing from book production. My experience on Wikipedia with subjects I know well is that, despite its claim of accuracy through the marketplace of ideas, it is significantly more prone to error than the older publications such as the Encyclopedia Britannica; its open entry format also makes it unstable, subject to the attentions of enthusiasts, cranks and people with axes to grind. What cannot be emphasized enough is that the main achievement of social media and the internet is that it facilitates lying, not least to ourselves. Trump has weaponized social media, turning it into a force multiplier for his lies, falsehoods and grievances, burying his opponents in a bewildering flood of invective.
It is remarkable that people still believe that the social media/internet cyber-complex is an avenue for self-expression and creativity. A new job description in public culture is ‘creatives’, but with no indication what the person is ‘creative’ at except for posting on the internet. A large percentage of users, roughly 20 to 30, describe themselves as content creatives. Some of their work, in online zines or platforms like Substack, may actually involve creating something, most frequently writing or photographs. Much of it though is advertising, not least for oneself. The phenomenon of the selfie is ubiquitous. Look at me! The reward isn’t the satisfaction of making something but the dopamine hit of getting ‘likes’ or comments. And there’s also the pathetic phenomenon of the parasocial relationship: imagining you are part of a community or are friends with someone because you follow them on social media. I’m besties with Dua Lipa myself.
As the internet collapsed traditional editorial guidelines and guardrails, so has it helped implode distinctions among and between types and genres of culture. Under modernity and now post-modernity, there has always been a churn between high and low, elite and vernacular. Most famously, probably, is how free verse interacted with formalism during the democratic nineteenth century. Jazz and folk rhythms invigorated classical music. But now these cultural and artistic interactions all seem to be going one way: everything is becoming popular culture. There is a political impetus to this change. The right’s attack on so-called ‘woke’ ideology evidences a disdain for culture across all disciplines. The administration’s attack on Washington’s Kennedy Center is a tip-off of how deep the vitriol against established artforms runs. The Kennedy Center has always been a reliable purveyor of mainstream, safe artistic productions for middle-class, middle-brow Americans who want a little culture: Broadway musicals, the established repertoire in classical music, ballet troupes doing selections from the canon. (It most recently was run by a Republican apparatchik who curried favour, to no avail, by mounting an egregious exhibition of George W. Bush’s painting.) That the administration would go after such a safe space is clear evidence of an anti-intellectualism that goes deep. The accompanying attacks on the universities and the Library of Congress are part of this violent antipathy to art, books, and thought itself.
But when the US president puts on a mixed martial arts event on the White House lawn, you can take that as an indicator of where things are going. Future historians will find a fruitful subject in the aesthetic and stylistic links between Trump and professional wrestling. I quite like car racing but putting on an Indy car race through the streets of Washington in late August smacks more of Nero flooding the Coliseum to hold naval battles than Monte Carlo. The destruction of the White House East Wing to build a ballroom, the uprooting of the famous Rose Garden to install a concrete ‘café’ space, the gimcrackery of the decorations (more gilt!) in the Oval Office and public spaces all indicate a contempt for historical precedent and American culture. The curated artworks of previous administrations – the two Bushes favoured emblematic American landscapes; the Obamas displayed the first abstractions (and were criticized for it, of course) – have been replaced by machine-painted photo-realist depictions of the President. Trump is all appetite, no taste. He likes his steak well done, with ketchup. And his late-evening snack is a McDonald’s Big Mac which he picks apart before chowing down.
It ought to be the easiest thing in the world to put on a celebration for America’s 250th birthday. Indeed, the Smithsonian assembled a programme displaying the full range of American culture, rich offerings from Springsteen to the National Symphony with accompanying exhibitions, lectures, readings and so on. The administration scrapped that plan for its ‘Country Fair’ concept, in which the several states (not everyone participated) displayed a motley collection of local wares on the National Mall. It was a failure conceptually and drew pitiful attendance. The ‘Country Fair’ idea was meant to appeal to states’ rights, to good old American values and plain folks, as opposed to the cosmopolitan elites with their un-American ideals and programmes. Looming over the ‘Country Fair’ was one of Trump’s triumphal arches, which, while striving for neoclassical monumentalism, looked like the pathetic ruin of some tin-pot dictator; hastily constructed, it delaminated in the Washington heat. The whole thing was a downmarket version of the National Socialist ‘Kinder, Küche, Kirche’, a call to a mythical past to resist the corruptions and anxieties of modernism. Amazingly, one of the Southern states in the ‘Fair’ included a baptismal tank where the converted could be saved. If you’re inclined, you can draw your own historical analogies to 1930s book burnings and the exhibition of ‘Degenerate Art’. Once as tragedy, then as farce, as the saying goes.
Despite the clear danger that Trump and his epigones pose to American democracy and the damage that they are doing every day, it’s hard to look away from the sheer buffoonery and incompetence of the man and his programme. America has the world’s best pool cleaning industry, yet the administration has botched the maintenance of the Reflecting Pool between the Washington and Lincoln monuments. As I write, the administration has launched a counter blast to the woke Smithsonian by putting on an exhibition – Passport to Patriotism – of properly patriotic art curated by the State Department and located at the Art Museum of the Americas. Concocted by Artificial Intelligence and machine-made, the ‘artworks’ displayed are not even as good as the kind of mass-produced paintings one finds in mid-level motels. In 1938 Germany mounted an exhibition called Great German Art as an opposition to the abstractions of ‘degenerate art’. It displayed traditional art that tended towards kitsch: bucolic landscapes, sentimental genre scenes and buxom milkmaids. An attempt at something similar, Passport to Patriotism can’t even rise to the level of kitsch: it’s dreck. Sparkly American flags abound and especially egregious are the airbrushed and outsized portraits of the Founders (Jefferson, Washington et al.) derived from original artwork by Gilbert Stuart and the Peales. Not only are they terrible, but you can go up the street to the National Portrait Gallery and see the originals! (If you don’t believe me, the New York Times of 30 July has illustrations as well as reporting on the corrupt dealings between curators and artists that went into the show’s making.)
The actuarial tables will take care of Mr. Trump. His declining popularity in his second term, as well as multiple setbacks both legally and politically, are a hopeful straw in the wind. What happens afterwards, as MAGA’s guiding light goes out, remains to be seen; one suspects the knives will come out as contenders jostle for the throne. Absent the fever dreams instigated by Trump, perhaps some of his supporters might conclude that ‘owning the Libs’ is not a viable programme for governance. Middle- and working-class supporters of the Republican Party might also think about whether their billionaire leaders have their best interests at heart. Awaiting that day, liberals of both the old fashioned and progressive kind need to harden themselves to resist where they can. It would be helpful if cultural leaders at universities, museums and elsewhere could articulate a stronger defence of the values of the humanities and science, including rationalism itself, than they have done so far. Personally, I’d like to see more politically engaged poetry and fiction, a counter culture if you will, grounded in carrying on the traditions of the past. There is also value in maintaining the traditions and lineage of the disciplines – a belief in the intrinsic value of the arts and humanities – especially when they’re under threat; as Elizabeth Bishop commanded, ‘Write it’. Politically, a complacent liberalism has declined into a programmatic formalism that does little to address the genuine hardship and bewilderment faced by ordinary people. Truth be told, the Democratic Party in the USA has given voters little reason to feel good about America since the end of the Vietnam War. Into that void has stepped the atavistic, toxic nationalism of MAGA. We should be chastened by the costs of our cultural and civic failures.
This article is taken from PN Review 292, Volume 53 Number 2, November - December 2026.
Further Reading:
More Articles by... (15)
Reports by... (7)
Poems by... (6)
Reviews by... (98)
Review of... (1)
